The All Blacks' 2025 season was a rollercoaster of highs and lows, leaving fans and critics alike divided. But here's the shocking truth: while some players soared, others stumbled, and Rieko Ioane’s once-promising career now hangs in the balance. After a decidedly mediocre year, his future in the black jersey is far from certain. But let’s dive deeper into the performances of every All Blacks back, where we’ll uncover standout stars, surprising struggles, and the controversial question: who truly deserves their spot in 2026?
Following the conclusion of Scott Robertson’s second year at the helm, we’ve rated each back out of 10, dissecting their contributions in a season that was as inconsistent as it was intriguing. The backline, once the All Blacks’ fortress, has struggled to find its rhythm since Robertson took charge post-2023 Rugby World Cup. Yet, amidst the chaos, a few individuals shone brightly.
Back Three
Will Jordan (8): The epitome of consistency, Jordan was a beacon of reliability whether at full-back or on the wing. His prowess under the high ball—an area where the All Blacks often faltered—was unmatched, and his try-scoring record (45 in 54 Tests) speaks for itself. In a season of uncertainty, Jordan was a rare constant.
Sevu Reece (4): Bursting onto the scene early, Reece’s form fizzled out midway through the Rugby Championship. A late flourish against Wales saved his rating from plummeting further, but at 30, his Test career seems to be on borrowed time. Is this the end for Reece, or can he rediscover his spark?
Rieko Ioane (3): Robertson’s faith in Ioane never wavered, but the Leinster back failed to repay it. Given a golden opportunity against Wales to stake his claim for 2026, Ioane’s performance was underwhelming, mirroring his entire campaign. Has Ioane’s time in the All Blacks jersey run its course, or can he turn it around?
Emoni Narawa (5): Limited opportunities didn’t stop Narawa from showcasing his potential. A season-ending injury against the Springboks cut short his promise, but if he returns fit, 2026 could be his breakout year.
Ruben Love (6): Often overlooked in favor of Beauden Barrett and Damian McKenzie, Love stepped up when called upon. However, like his back three teammates, his aerial skills need sharpening. Is Love the future at 10, or will he remain in the shadows of Barrett and McKenzie?
Leroy Carter (6): A sensational start with three tries in as many Tests was tempered by a struggling northern hemisphere tour. Carter’s weaknesses were exposed, but his potential remains undeniable. Can he address his flaws and become a mainstay in 2026?
Caleb Clarke (6): Injuries limited Clarke’s impact, but when he played, he impressed. His talent is undeniable, but 2025 wasn’t his year. Will Clarke finally fulfill his potential next season?
Centres
Billy Proctor (5): Tasked with filling the void at 13, Proctor’s technical prowess didn’t translate into consistent performances. Is he the long-term solution, or will Robertson look elsewhere?
Jordie Barrett (8): One of New Zealand’s brightest stars, Barrett’s absence in the defeat to England was keenly felt. His ability to run, carry, and pass makes him a triple threat and one of the world’s best inside centres.
Quinn Tupaea (7): Starting as a bench player, Tupaea seized his chance after Proctor’s omission, delivering standout performances at both 12 and 13. Is he the future of the All Blacks midfield?
Timoci Tavatavanawai (4): Limited opportunities and an untimely injury derailed his campaign. Did Robertson miss a trick by not giving him more chances?
Anton Lienert-Brown (4): Like Reece, Lienert-Brown’s Test career appears to be winding down. Sporadic appearances and a lack of standout moments made for an underwhelming year. Is it time to move on, or can he rediscover his best form?
Leicester Fainga’anuku (7): Deployed as a wing, Fainga’anuku’s future likely lies at 13. His late-season performances added much-needed thrust to the backline. Will 2026 be his year to shine in the centres?
Fly-Halves
Beauden Barrett (7): Solidified his position as the first-choice 10, but his end-of-year tour performances raised questions. Is Barrett still the man for the job, or is it time for a change?
Damian McKenzie (6): A mixed bag for McKenzie, who couldn’t displace Barrett but had his moments, including a match-winning performance against Scotland. Can he finally claim the 10 jersey in 2026?
Scrum-Halves
Cam Roigard (9): With Antoine Dupont sidelined, Roigard staked his claim as the world’s best scrum-half. His performances were nothing short of superb, making him New Zealand’s standout player in 2025. Is Roigard the future of All Blacks rugby?
Cortez Ratima (5): Stagnation is Ratima’s biggest enemy. While his passing and speed are sharp, his slow service and subpar kicking game need urgent improvement. Can he step up in 2026, or will he be left behind?
Noah Hotham (3): An injury-plagued season limited Hotham’s impact, but his potential is undeniable. Will next year be his chance to shine?
Finlay Christie (6): Despite limited opportunities, Christie outperformed some of his competitors. His performance against the Springboks and cameo in Cardiff were highlights. Is he being overlooked for the World Cup squad?
Kyle Preston (3): Barely featured in 2025, but a strong Super Rugby campaign could put him back in contention. Can Preston force his way into Robertson’s plans?
And this is the part most people miss: The All Blacks’ backline is at a crossroads. While Roigard and Jordan offer hope, questions linger over key positions. Who will step up in 2026? And is Rieko Ioane’s career truly over, or can he defy the odds? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—this debate is far from over.
